Judgement of the Supreme Court of India on whether a Parliamentary Standing Committee (PSC) report can be placed reliance upon for adjudication of a fact in issue, 09/05/2018

  • 09/05/2018

Judgement of the Supreme Court of India in the matter of Kalpana Mehta & Others Vs Union of India & Others dated 09/05/2018 on whether a Parliamentary Standing Committee (PSC) report can be placed reliance upon for adjudication of a fact in issue and also for what other purposes it can be taken aid of.

The main points of the judgement are the following:

1. When a party relies on any fact stated in the Parliamentary Committee Report as the matter of noticing an event or history no exception can be taken on such reliance of the report. However, no party can be allowed to 'question'   or 'impeach' report of Parliamentary Committee.

2. Admissibility of a Parliamentary Committee Report  in evidence does not mean that facts stated in the Report stand proved. When issues of facts come before a Court of law for adjudication, the Court is to decide the issues on the basis of evidence and materials brought before it. 

blog comments powered by Disqus